House roll call 50 · 61st Congress · Feb 10, 1910
On adoption of substitute resolution sponsored by the minority members of the judiciary committee, opposing the majority resolution (h. Res.) concerning privile
On Feb 10, 1910, the House voted 56–173. Result: failed. By party: Republicans 17–110, Democrats 44–67. It was a bipartisan vote: majorities of both parties voted no. 61 members voted against their own party.
During the 61st Congress (1909–1910), William Howard Taft was president, and Republicans held majorities in both the House and Senate.
- Yes
- 56
- No
- 173
- Did not vote
- 164
- Date
- Feb 10, 1910
By party
- Democrats44 yes · 67 no · 69 didn’t vote
- Republicans17 yes · 110 no · 95 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- Stanley Hubert Dent Jr. D-AL voted yes
- Henry De Lamar Clayton D-AL voted yes
- William Benjamin Craig D-AL voted yes
- James Thomas Heflin D-AL voted yes
- John Lawson Burnett D-AL voted yes
- Oscar Wilder Underwood D-AL voted yes
- Robert Bruce Macon D-AR voted yes
- William Allan Oldfield D-AR voted yes
- John Andrew Martin D-CO voted yes
- Edward Stevens Henry R-CT voted yes
- John Albert Tiffin Hull R-IA voted yes
- William Darius Jamieson D-IA voted yes
- Elbert Hamilton Hubbard R-IA voted yes
- Thomas Gallagher D-IL voted yes
- James McMahon Graham D-IL voted yes
- William August Rodenberg R-IL voted yes
- Ralph Wilbur Moss D-IN voted yes
- Charles Alexander Korbly D-IN voted yes
- Cyrus Cline D-IN voted yes
- Ollie Murray James D-KY voted yes
- James Campbell Cantrill D-KY voted yes
- Robert Foligny Broussard D-LA voted yes
- John Thomas Watkins D-LA voted yes
- Samuel Walker Mccall R-MA voted yes
- James Albertus Tawney R-MN voted yes
- Clarence Benjamin Miller R-MN voted yes
- Charles Ferris Booher D-MO voted yes
- James Beauchamp (Champ) Clark D-MO voted yes
- Patrick Francis Gill D-MO voted yes
- Charles Henry Morgan R-MO voted yes
- Ezekiel Samuel Candler Jr. D-MS voted yes
- Thomas Upton Sisson D-MS voted yes
- Eaton Jackson Bowers D-MS voted yes
- William Alexander Dickson D-MS voted yes
- Charles Randolph Thomas D-NC voted yes
- John Arthur Maguire D-NE voted yes
- George William Norris R-NE voted yes
- Richard Wayne Parker R-NJ voted yes
- William Halsted Wiley R-NJ voted yes
- James Alphonsus Hamill D-NJ voted yes
- John Joseph Fitzgerald D-NY voted yes
- William Sulzer D-NY voted yes
- Daniel Angelus Driscoll D-NY voted yes
- Isaac R. Sherwood D-OH voted yes
- Edward Livingston Taylor Jr. R-OH voted yes
- William Aubrey Thomas R-OH voted yes
- James Henry Cassidy R-OH voted yes
- Scott Ferris D-OK voted yes
- Thomas David Nicholls D-PA voted yes
- Henry Wilbur Palmer R-PA voted yes
- John Hoover Rothermel D-PA voted yes
- John Geiser Mchenry D-PA voted yes
- Benjamin Kurtz Focht R-PA voted yes
- Alexander Mitchell Palmer D-PA voted yes
- John Austin Moon D-TN voted yes
- Finis James Garrett D-TN voted yes
- John Matthew Moore D-TX voted yes
- George Farmer Burgess D-TX voted yes
- Robert Lee Henry D-TX voted yes
- John Hall Stephens D-TX voted yes
- Henry Allen Cooper R-WI voted yes
How each representative voted: Yes
- Stanley Hubert Dent Jr. D-AL
- Henry De Lamar Clayton D-AL
- William Benjamin Craig D-AL
- James Thomas Heflin D-AL
- John Lawson Burnett D-AL
- Oscar Wilder Underwood D-AL
- Robert Bruce Macon D-AR
- William Allan Oldfield D-AR
- John Andrew Martin D-CO
- Edward Stevens Henry R-CT
- John Albert Tiffin Hull R-IA
- William Darius Jamieson D-IA
- Elbert Hamilton Hubbard R-IA
- Thomas Gallagher D-IL
- James McMahon Graham D-IL
- William August Rodenberg R-IL
- Ralph Wilbur Moss D-IN
- Charles Alexander Korbly D-IN
- Cyrus Cline D-IN
- Ollie Murray James D-KY
- James Campbell Cantrill D-KY
- Robert Foligny Broussard D-LA
- John Thomas Watkins D-LA
- Samuel Walker Mccall R-MA
- James Albertus Tawney R-MN
- Clarence Benjamin Miller R-MN
- Charles Ferris Booher D-MO
- James Beauchamp (Champ) Clark D-MO
- Patrick Francis Gill D-MO
- Charles Henry Morgan R-MO
- Ezekiel Samuel Candler Jr. D-MS
- Thomas Upton Sisson D-MS
- Eaton Jackson Bowers D-MS
- William Alexander Dickson D-MS
- Charles Randolph Thomas D-NC
- John Arthur Maguire D-NE
- George William Norris R-NE
- Richard Wayne Parker R-NJ
- William Halsted Wiley R-NJ
- James Alphonsus Hamill D-NJ
- John Joseph Fitzgerald D-NY
- William Sulzer D-NY
- Daniel Angelus Driscoll D-NY
- Isaac R. Sherwood D-OH
- Edward Livingston Taylor Jr. R-OH
- William Aubrey Thomas R-OH
- James Henry Cassidy R-OH
- Scott Ferris D-OK
- Thomas David Nicholls D-PA
- Henry Wilbur Palmer R-PA
- John Hoover Rothermel D-PA
- John Geiser Mchenry D-PA
- Benjamin Kurtz Focht R-PA
- Alexander Mitchell Palmer D-PA
- John Austin Moon D-TN
- Finis James Garrett D-TN
- John Matthew Moore D-TX
- George Farmer Burgess D-TX
- Robert Lee Henry D-TX
- John Hall Stephens D-TX
- Henry Allen Cooper R-WI
How each representative voted: No
- John Charles Floyd D-AR
- William Ben Cravens D-AR
- Charles Chester Reid D-AR
- Joseph Taylor Robinson D-AR
- William Fellows Englebright R-CA
- Joseph Russell Knowland R-CA
- Everis Anson Hayes R-CA
- James Mclachlan R-CA
- Edward Thomas Taylor D-CO
- Edwin Werter Higgins R-CT
- Stephen Milancthon Sparkman D-FL
- Dannite Hill Mays D-FL
- Charles Gordon Edwards D-GA
- William Charles Adamson D-GA
- William Marcellus Howard D-GA
- Thomas Montgomery Bell D-GA
- William Gordon Brantley D-GA
- James William Good R-IA
- Frank Plowman Woods R-IA
- Thomas Ray Hamer R-ID
- James Robert Mann R-IL
- William Warfield Wilson R-IL
- William James Moxley R-IL
- Charles Eugene Fuller R-IL
- Frank Orren Lowden R-IL
- George Washington Prince R-IL
- Joseph Verdi Graff R-IL
- John Allen Sterling R-IL
- Henry Thomas Rainey D-IL
- Martin David Foster D-IL
- Pleasant Thomas Chapman R-IL
- John William Boehne D-IN
- William Allen Cullop D-IN
- William Elijah Cox D-IN
- Lincoln Dixon D-IN
- William Oscar Barnard R-IN
- Martin Andrew Morrison D-IN
- George Washington Rauch D-IN
- Henry A. Barnhart D-IN
- Charles Frederick Scott R-KS
- Philip Pitt Campbell R-KS
- Edmond Haggard Madison R-KS
- Victor Murdock R-KS
- Joseph Swagar Sherley D-KY
- Harvey Helm D-KY
- Joseph Bentley Bennett R-KY
- Don Calvin Edwards R-KY
- Joseph Eugene Ransdell D-LA
- Robert Charles Wickliffe D-LA
- Arsène Paulin Pujo D-LA
- George Pelton Lawrence R-MA
- Charles Grenfill Washburn R-MA
- Charles Quincy Tirrell R-MA
- John Wingate Weeks R-MA
- William Stedman Greene R-MA
- Amos Lawrence Allen R-ME
- Edwin Denby R-MI
- Charles Elroy Townsend R-MI
- Edward La Rue Hamilton R-MI
- Gerrit John Diekema R-MI
- Joseph Warren Fordney R-MI
- Francis Henry Dodds R-MI
- Horace Olin Young R-MI
- Winfield Scott Hammond D-MN
- Charles Russell Davis R-MN
- Charles August Lindbergh R-MN
- Andrew John Volstead R-MN
- Halvor Steenerson R-MN
- James Tilghman Lloyd D-MO
- William Waller Rucker D-MO
- Joshua Willis Alexander D-MO
- Clement Cabell Dickinson D-MO
- Courtney Walker Hamlin D-MO
- Richard Bartholdt R-MO
- Harry Marcy Coudrey R-MO
- Politte Elvins R-MO
- Thomas Spight D-MS
- Benjamin Grubb Humphreys D-MS
- James William Collier D-MS
- John Humphrey Small D-NC
- Claude Kitchin D-NC
- Robert Newton Page D-NC
- Charles Holden Cowles R-NC
- Edwin Yates Webb D-NC
- John Gaston Grant R-NC
- Asle Jorgenson Gronna R-ND
- Louis Benjamin Hanna R-ND
- James Polk Latta D-NE
- Edmund Howard Hinshaw R-NE
- Moses Pierce Kinkaid R-NE
- Cyrus Adams Sulloway R-NH
- John James Gardner R-NJ
- Benjamin Franklin Howell R-NJ
- Ira Wells Wood R-NJ
- William Hughes D-NJ
- Eugene Francis Kinkead D-NJ
- George Arthur Bartlett D-NV
- William Willets Cocks R-NY
- Charles Blakeslee Law R-NY
- William Musgrave Calder R-NY
- Charles Vincent Fornes D-NY
- Michael Francis Conry D-NY
- William Forte Willett Jr. D-NY
- Jacob Van Vechten Olcott R-NY
- William Stiles Bennet R-NY
- Joseph Aloysius Goulden D-NY
- Thomas Wilson Bradley R-NY
- Hamilton Fish R-NY
- George Newell Southwick R-NY
- George Roland Malby R-NY
- Charles Luman Knapp R-NY
- Michael Edward Driscoll R-NY
- John Wilbur Dwight R-NY
- Sereno Elisha Payne R-NY
- Jacob Sloat Fassett R-NY
- James Samuel Simmons R-NY
- Edward Butterfield Vreeland R-NY
- James Middleton Cox D-OH
- William Ellsworth Tou Velle D-OH
- Matthew Rombach Denver D-OH
- Joseph Warren Keifer R-OH
- Adna Romulus Johnson R-OH
- Carl Carey Anderson D-OH
- James Joyce R-OH
- David Adams Hollingsworth R-OH
- William Albert Ashbrook D-OH
- James Kennedy R-OH
- Leonard Paul Howland R-OH
- Dick Thompson Morgan R-OK
- Willis Chatman Hawley R-OR
- William Russell Ellis R-OR
- Joseph Hampton Moore R-PA
- Reuben Osborne Moon R-PA
- William Walker Foulkrod R-PA
- George Deardorff Mccreary R-PA
- Thomas Stalker Butler R-PA
- Irving Price Wanger R-PA
- Marlin Edgar Olmsted R-PA
- John Merriman Reynolds R-PA
- Daniel Franklin Lafean R-PA
- Jonathan Nicholas Langham R-PA
- Nelson Platt Wheeler R-PA
- James Francis Burke R-PA
- Andrew Jackson Barchfeld R-PA
- William Paine Sheffield R-RI
- James Edwin Ellerbe D-SC
- Asbury Francis Lever D-SC
- Charles Henry Burke R-SD
- Eben Wever Martin R-SD
- Walter Preston Brownlow R-TN
- Richard Wilson Austin R-TN
- William Cannon Houston D-TN
- Lemuel Phillips Padgett D-TN
- Thetus Willrette Sims D-TN
- Morris Sheppard D-TX
- Martin Dies D-TX
- James Andrew (Jack) Beall D-TX
- Rufus Hardy D-TX
- Alexander White Gregg D-TX
- Oscar William Gillespie D-TX
- John Nance Garner D-TX
- William Robert Smith D-TX
- Charles Creighton Carlin D-VA
- Campbell Bascom Slemp R-VA
- Henry De La Warr Flood D-VA
- David Johnson Foster R-VT
- William Ewart Humphrey R-WA
- Miles Poindexter R-WA
- John Mandt Nelson R-WI
- Arthur William Kopp R-WI
- William Joseph Cary R-WI
- William Henry Stafford R-WI
- Gustav Küstermann R-WI
- Elmer Addison Morse R-WI
- Irvine Luther Lenroot R-WI
- James Anthony Hughes R-WV
- Frank Wheeler Mondell R-WY
Did not vote
- George Washington Taylor D-AL
- Richmond Pearson Hobson D-AL
- William Richardson D-AL
- Robert Minor Wallace D-AR
- Duncan E. Mckinlay R-CA
- Julius Kahn R-CA
- James Carson Needham R-CA
- Sylvester Clark Smith R-CA
- Atterson Walden Rucker D-CO
- Nehemiah Day Sperry R-CT
- Ebenezer J. Hill R-CT
- John Quillin Tilson R-CT
- William Henry Heald R-DE
- Frank Clark D-FL
- James Mathews Griggs D-GA
- Seaborn Anderson Roddenbery D-GA
- Dudley Mays Hughes D-GA
- Leonidas Felix Livingston D-GA
- Charles Lafayette Bartlett D-GA
- Gordon Lee D-GA
- Thomas William Hardwick D-GA
- Charles Augustus Kennedy R-IA
- Albert Foster Dawson R-IA
- Charles Edgar Pickett R-IA
- Gilbert Nelson Haugen R-IA
- Nathan Edward Kendall R-IA
- Walter Inglewood Smith R-IA
- Martin Barnaby Madden R-IL
- James Thomas Mcdermott D-IL
- Adolph Joachim Sabath D-IL
- William Lorimer R-IL
- Frederick Lundin R-IL
- Henry Sherman Boutell R-IL
- George Edmund Foss R-IL
- Howard Malcolm Snapp R-IL
- James Mckinney R-IL
- Joseph Gurney Cannon R-IL
- William Brown Mckinley R-IL
- Napoleon Bonaparte Thistlewood R-IL
- John Alfred Adair D-IN
- Edgar Dean Crumpacker R-IN
- Daniel Read Anthony Jr. R-KS
- James Monroe Miller R-KS
- William Alexander Calderhead R-KS
- William Augustus Reeder R-KS
- Augustus Owsley Stanley D-KY
- Robert Young Thomas Jr. D-KY
- Ben Johnson D-KY
- Joseph Lafayette Rhinock D-KY
- John Wesley Langley R-KY
- Albert Estopinal D-LA
- Henry Garland Dupré D-LA
- Samuel Louis Gilmore D-LA
- Frederick Huntington Gillett R-MA
- John Joseph Mitchell D-MA
- Butler Ames R-MA
- Augustus Peabody Gardner R-MA
- Ernest William Roberts R-MA
- John Austin Keliher D-MA
- Joseph Francis O'Connell D-MA
- Andrew James Peters D-MA
- Eugene Noble Foss D-MA
- William Croad Lovering R-MA
- James Harry Covington D-MD
- Joshua Frederick Cockey Talbott D-MD
- John Kronmiller R-MD
- John Gill Jr. D-MD
- Sydney Emanuel Mudd R-MD
- George Alexander Pearre R-MD
- John Philip Swasey R-ME
- Edwin Chick Burleigh R-ME
- Frank Edward Guernsey R-ME
- Washington Gardner R-MI
- Samuel William Smith R-MI
- Henry Gordon Mcmorran R-MI
- James Campbell Mclaughlin R-MI
- George Alvin Loud R-MI
- Frederick Clement Stevens R-MN
- Frank Mellen Nye R-MN
- William Patterson Borland D-MO
- David Albaugh De Armond D-MO
- Dorsey William Shackleford D-MO
- Charles Augustus Crow R-MO
- Arthur Phillips Murphy R-MO
- Adam Monroe Byrd D-MS
- Charles Nelson Pray R-MT
- Edward William Pou D-NC
- John Motley Morehead R-NC
- Hannibal Lafayette Godwin D-NC
- Gilbert Monell Hitchcock D-NE
- Frank Dunklee Currier R-NH
- Henry Clay Loudenslager R-NJ
- Charles Newell Fowler R-NJ
- George Henry Lindsay D-NY
- Otto Godfrey Foelker R-NY
- Richard Young R-NY
- Daniel Joseph Riordan D-NY
- Henry Mayer Goldfogle D-NY
- Herbert Parsons R-NY
- Francis Burton Harrison D-NY
- John Emory Andrus R-NY
- William Henry Draper R-NY
- George Winthrop Fairchild R-NY
- Cyrus Durey R-NY
- Charles Stephen Millington R-NY
- James Breck Perkins R-NY
- James Smith Havens D-NY
- De Alva Stanwood Alexander R-NY
- Nicholas Longworth R-OH
- Herman Philip Goebel R-OH
- Timothy Thomas Ansberry D-OH
- Ralph Dayton Cole R-OH
- Albert Douglas R-OH
- William Graves Sharp D-OH
- Bird Segle Mcguire R-OK
- Charles Edward Creager R-OK
- Charles David Carter D-OK
- Henry Harrison Bingham R-PA
- Joel Cook R-PA
- William Walton Griest R-PA
- Alfred Buckwalter Garner R-PA
- Charles Clarence Pratt R-PA
- William Bauchop Wilson D-PA
- Charles Frederick Barclay R-PA
- George Franklin Huff R-PA
- Allen Foster Cooper R-PA
- John Kinley Tener R-PA
- Arthur Laban Bates R-PA
- William Harrison Graham R-PA
- John Dalzell R-PA
- Adin Ballou Capron R-RI
- George Swinton Legaré D-SC
- James O'Hanlon Patterson D-SC
- Wyatt Aiken D-SC
- Joseph Travis Johnson D-SC
- David Edward Finley D-SC
- Zachary David Massey R-TN
- Cordell Hull D-TN
- Joseph Wellington Byrns D-TN
- George Washington Gordon D-TN
- Gordon James Russell D-TX
- Robert Maclin Lively D-TX
- Choice Boswell Randell D-TX
- Albert Sidney Burleson D-TX
- James Luther Slayden D-TX
- Joseph Howell R-UT
- William Atkinson Jones D-VA
- Harry Lee Maynard D-VA
- John Lamb D-VA
- Francis Rives Lassiter D-VA
- Robert Turnbull D-VA
- Edward Watts Saunders D-VA
- Carter Glass D-VA
- James Hay D-VA
- Frank Plumley R-VT
- Francis Wellington Cushman R-WA
- William Wallace Mccredie R-WA
- Charles Herman Weisse D-WI
- John Jacob Esch R-WI
- James Henry Davidson R-WI
- William Pallister Hubbard R-WV
- George Cookman Sturgiss R-WV
- Joseph Holt Gaines R-WV
- Harry Chapman Woodyard R-WV
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “On adoption of substitute resolution…: House Vote, Feb 10, 1910,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/61-H-50/on-adoption-of-substitute-resolution-sponsored-by-the-minority (accessed 2026-10-17).