House roll call 147 · 60th Congress · May 11, 1908
To suspend the rules and pass S. J. RES. 51 (35 stat 577, 5/25/08) providing additional lands for idaho under the carey act.
On May 11, 1908, the House voted 89–98 (SJR 51). Result: failed. By party: Republicans 73–31, Democrats 17–67. It was a split vote: the parties took opposite sides, with some members crossing over. 48 members voted against their own party.
During the 60th Congress (1907–1908), Theodore Roosevelt was president, and Republicans held majorities in both the House and Senate.
- Yes
- 89
- No
- 98
- Did not vote
- 211
- Date
- May 11, 1908
By party
- Democrats17 yes · 67 no · 86 didn’t vote
- Republicans73 yes · 31 no · 124 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- William Benjamin Craig D-AL voted yes
- James Thomas Heflin D-AL voted yes
- John Lawson Burnett D-AL voted yes
- Oscar Wilder Underwood D-AL voted yes
- Robert Bruce Macon D-AR voted yes
- William Gordon Brantley D-GA voted yes
- Charles Augustus Kennedy R-IA voted no
- Albert Foster Dawson R-IA voted no
- Daniel Webster Hamilton D-IA voted yes
- John Albert Tiffin Hull R-IA voted no
- Martin Barnaby Madden R-IL voted no
- James Robert Mann R-IL voted no
- William Warfield Wilson R-IL voted no
- Philip Knopf R-IL voted no
- Charles Eugene Fuller R-IL voted no
- Frank Orren Lowden R-IL voted no
- Philip Pitt Campbell R-KS voted no
- James Monroe Miller R-KS voted no
- William Augustus Reeder R-KS voted no
- Victor Murdock R-KS voted no
- George Pelton Lawrence R-MA voted no
- Frederick Huntington Gillett R-MA voted no
- Charles Grenfill Washburn R-MA voted no
- Samuel Walker Mccall R-MA voted no
- Joseph Francis O'Connell D-MA voted yes
- Charles Elroy Townsend R-MI voted no
- Frank Mellen Nye R-MN voted no
- Hannibal Lafayette Godwin D-NC voted yes
- Ernest Mark Pollard R-NE voted no
- John Frank Boyd R-NE voted no
- Edmund Howard Hinshaw R-NE voted no
- Cyrus Adams Sulloway R-NH voted no
- Frank Dunklee Currier R-NH voted no
- Charles Vincent Fornes D-NY voted yes
- Jacob Van Vechten Olcott R-NY voted no
- Joseph Aloysius Goulden D-NY voted yes
- John Emory Andrus R-NY voted no
- William Henry Draper R-NY voted no
- Michael Edward Driscoll R-NY voted no
- John Wilbur Dwight R-NY voted no
- Sereno Elisha Payne R-NY voted no
- Scott Ferris D-OK voted yes
- David Edward Finley D-SC voted yes
- James Edwin Ellerbe D-SC voted yes
- Asbury Francis Lever D-SC voted yes
- George Farmer Burgess D-TX voted yes
- James Hay D-VA voted yes
- Kittredge Haskins R-VT voted no
How each representative voted: Yes
- William Benjamin Craig D-AL
- James Thomas Heflin D-AL
- John Lawson Burnett D-AL
- Oscar Wilder Underwood D-AL
- Robert Bruce Macon D-AR
- William Fellows Englebright R-CA
- Duncan E. Mckinlay R-CA
- James Carson Needham R-CA
- James Mclachlan R-CA
- Sylvester Clark Smith R-CA
- Robert William Bonynge R-CO
- Nehemiah Day Sperry R-CT
- William Gordon Brantley D-GA
- Daniel Webster Hamilton D-IA
- Burton Lee French R-ID
- George Edmund Foss R-IL
- Howard Malcolm Snapp R-IL
- Joseph Verdi Graff R-IL
- Joseph Gurney Cannon R-IL
- William Brown Mckinley R-IL
- Pleasant Thomas Chapman R-IL
- James Eli Watson R-IN
- Edgar Dean Crumpacker R-IN
- Clarence Chauncey Gilhams R-IN
- William Alexander Calderhead R-KS
- Joseph Francis O'Connell D-MA
- William Stedman Greene R-MA
- William Croad Lovering R-MA
- Amos Lawrence Allen R-ME
- Washington Gardner R-MI
- Archibald Bard Darragh R-MI
- Andrew John Volstead R-MN
- James Adam Bede R-MN
- Halvor Steenerson R-MN
- Edgar Clarence Ellis R-MO
- Henry Stewart Caulfield R-MO
- Charles Nelson Pray R-MT
- Hannibal Lafayette Godwin D-NC
- George William Norris R-NE
- Moses Pierce Kinkaid R-NE
- Henry Clay Loudenslager R-NJ
- John James Gardner R-NJ
- George Ernest Waldo R-NY
- Charles Vincent Fornes D-NY
- Herbert Parsons R-NY
- William Stiles Bennet R-NY
- Joseph Aloysius Goulden D-NY
- Thomas Wilson Bradley R-NY
- Samuel Mcmillan R-NY
- George Newell Southwick R-NY
- George Roland Malby R-NY
- Jacob Sloat Fassett R-NY
- De Alva Stanwood Alexander R-NY
- John Eugene Harding R-OH
- Joseph Warren Keifer R-OH
- Ralph Dayton Cole R-OH
- Edward Livingston Taylor Jr. R-OH
- Grant Earl Mouser R-OH
- Jay Ford Laning R-OH
- William Aubrey Thomas R-OH
- Leonard Paul Howland R-OH
- Bird Segle Mcguire R-OK
- Scott Ferris D-OK
- Willis Chatman Hawley R-OR
- William Russell Ellis R-OR
- Joel Cook R-PA
- Joseph Hampton Moore R-PA
- William Walker Foulkrod R-PA
- Irving Price Wanger R-PA
- Daniel Franklin Lafean R-PA
- George Franklin Huff R-PA
- Allen Foster Cooper R-PA
- Joseph Grant Beale R-PA
- John Dalzell R-PA
- James Francis Burke R-PA
- Adin Ballou Capron R-RI
- David Edward Finley D-SC
- James Edwin Ellerbe D-SC
- Asbury Francis Lever D-SC
- Philo Hall R-SD
- Walter Preston Brownlow R-TN
- George Farmer Burgess D-TX
- Joseph Howell R-UT
- James Hay D-VA
- Francis Wellington Cushman R-WA
- Wesley Livsey Jones R-WA
- William Ewart Humphrey R-WA
- Gustav Küstermann R-WI
- Harry Chapman Woodyard R-WV
- Frank Wheeler Mondell R-WY
How each representative voted: No
- Henry De Lamar Clayton D-AL
- William Richardson D-AL
- John Charles Floyd D-AR
- Charles Chester Reid D-AR
- Robert Minor Wallace D-AR
- Stephen Milancthon Sparkman D-FL
- Frank Clark D-FL
- William Charles Adamson D-GA
- Gordon Lee D-GA
- Charles Augustus Kennedy R-IA
- Albert Foster Dawson R-IA
- John Albert Tiffin Hull R-IA
- Martin Barnaby Madden R-IL
- James Robert Mann R-IL
- William Warfield Wilson R-IL
- Adolph Joachim Sabath D-IL
- Philip Knopf R-IL
- Charles Eugene Fuller R-IL
- Frank Orren Lowden R-IL
- Martin David Foster D-IL
- William Elijah Cox D-IN
- John Alfred Adair D-IN
- George Washington Rauch D-IN
- Philip Pitt Campbell R-KS
- James Monroe Miller R-KS
- William Augustus Reeder R-KS
- Victor Murdock R-KS
- Ben Johnson D-KY
- Joseph Swagar Sherley D-KY
- William Preston Kimball D-KY
- Harvey Helm D-KY
- John Thomas Watkins D-LA
- Joseph Eugene Ransdell D-LA
- George Kent Favrot D-LA
- George Pelton Lawrence R-MA
- Frederick Huntington Gillett R-MA
- Charles Grenfill Washburn R-MA
- Samuel Walker Mccall R-MA
- John Austin Keliher D-MA
- John Gill Jr. D-MD
- Charles Elroy Townsend R-MI
- Frank Mellen Nye R-MN
- David Albaugh De Armond D-MO
- Courtney Walker Hamlin D-MO
- James Beauchamp (Champ) Clark D-MO
- Joseph James Russell D-MO
- Thomas Hackney D-MO
- Ezekiel Samuel Candler Jr. D-MS
- Thomas Spight D-MS
- Wilson Shedric Hill D-MS
- Eaton Jackson Bowers D-MS
- John Sharp Williams D-MS
- Claude Kitchin D-NC
- Charles Randolph Thomas D-NC
- Robert Newton Page D-NC
- Ernest Mark Pollard R-NE
- John Frank Boyd R-NE
- Edmund Howard Hinshaw R-NE
- Cyrus Adams Sulloway R-NH
- Frank Dunklee Currier R-NH
- William Hughes D-NJ
- John Joseph Fitzgerald D-NY
- William Bourke Cockran D-NY
- William Forte Willett Jr. D-NY
- Jacob Van Vechten Olcott R-NY
- John Emory Andrus R-NY
- William Henry Draper R-NY
- Michael Edward Driscoll R-NY
- John Wilbur Dwight R-NY
- Sereno Elisha Payne R-NY
- William Ellsworth Tou Velle D-OH
- Timothy Thomas Ansberry D-OH
- Matthew Rombach Denver D-OH
- George Washington Kipp D-PA
- Daniel Larned Davis Granger D-RI
- James O'Hanlon Patterson D-SC
- Joseph Travis Johnson D-SC
- John Austin Moon D-TN
- Cordell Hull D-TN
- William Cannon Houston D-TN
- John Wesley Gaines D-TN
- Lemuel Phillips Padgett D-TN
- Thetus Willrette Sims D-TN
- Morris Sheppard D-TX
- Samuel Bronson Cooper D-TX
- Gordon James Russell D-TX
- Choice Boswell Randell D-TX
- James Andrew (Jack) Beall D-TX
- Rufus Hardy D-TX
- John Matthew Moore D-TX
- Albert Sidney Burleson D-TX
- Robert Lee Henry D-TX
- Oscar William Gillespie D-TX
- John Hall Stephens D-TX
- John Nance Garner D-TX
- John Lamb D-VA
- Francis Rives Lassiter D-VA
- Kittredge Haskins R-VT
Did not vote
- George Washington Taylor D-AL
- Ariosto Appling Wiley D-AL
- Oliver Cicero Wiley D-AL
- Richmond Pearson Hobson D-AL
- Stephen Brundidge Jr. D-AR
- William Ben Cravens D-AR
- Joseph Taylor Robinson D-AR
- Joseph Russell Knowland R-CA
- Julius Kahn R-CA
- Everis Anson Hayes R-CA
- Warren Armstrong Haggott R-CO
- George Washington Cook R-CO
- Edward Stevens Henry R-CT
- Edwin Werter Higgins R-CT
- Ebenezer J. Hill R-CT
- George Leavens Lilley R-CT
- Hiram Rodney Burton R-DE
- William Bailey Lamar D-FL
- Charles Gordon Edwards D-GA
- James Mathews Griggs D-GA
- Elijah Banks Lewis D-GA
- Leonidas Felix Livingston D-GA
- Charles Lafayette Bartlett D-GA
- William Marcellus Howard D-GA
- Thomas Montgomery Bell D-GA
- Thomas William Hardwick D-GA
- Benjamin Pixley Birdsall R-IA
- Gilbert Nelson Haugen R-IA
- Robert Gordon Cousins R-IA
- William Peters Hepburn R-IA
- Walter Inglewood Smith R-IA
- James Perry Conner R-IA
- Elbert Hamilton Hubbard R-IA
- James Thomas Mcdermott D-IL
- William Lorimer R-IL
- Charles Mcgavin R-IL
- Henry Sherman Boutell R-IL
- James Mckinney R-IL
- George Washington Prince R-IL
- John Allen Sterling R-IL
- Henry Thomas Rainey D-IL
- Ben Franklin Caldwell D-IL
- William August Rodenberg R-IL
- Napoleon Bonaparte Thistlewood R-IL
- John Hopkins Foster R-IN
- John Crawford Chaney R-IN
- Lincoln Dixon D-IN
- Elias Selah Holliday R-IN
- Jesse Overstreet R-IN
- Charles Beary Landis R-IN
- Abraham Lincoln Brick R-IN
- Henry A. Barnhart D-IN
- Daniel Read Anthony Jr. R-KS
- Charles Frederick Scott R-KS
- Edmond Haggard Madison R-KS
- Ollie Murray James D-KY
- Augustus Owsley Stanley D-KY
- Addison Davis James R-KY
- Joseph Lafayette Rhinock D-KY
- Joseph Bentley Bennett R-KY
- John Wesley Langley R-KY
- Don Calvin Edwards R-KY
- Adolph Meyer D-LA
- Albert Estopinal D-LA
- Robert Charles Davey D-LA
- Robert Foligny Broussard D-LA
- Arsène Paulin Pujo D-LA
- Charles Quincy Tirrell R-MA
- Butler Ames R-MA
- Augustus Peabody Gardner R-MA
- Ernest William Roberts R-MA
- Andrew James Peters D-MA
- John Wingate Weeks R-MA
- William Humphreys Jackson R-MD
- Joshua Frederick Cockey Talbott D-MD
- Harry Benjamin Wolf D-MD
- Sydney Emanuel Mudd R-MD
- George Alexander Pearre R-MD
- Charles Edgar Littlefield R-ME
- John Philip Swasey R-ME
- Edwin Chick Burleigh R-ME
- Frank Edward Guernsey R-ME
- Llewellyn Powers R-ME
- Edwin Denby R-MI
- Edward La Rue Hamilton R-MI
- Gerrit John Diekema R-MI
- Samuel William Smith R-MI
- Henry Gordon Mcmorran R-MI
- Joseph Warren Fordney R-MI
- James Campbell Mclaughlin R-MI
- George Alvin Loud R-MI
- Horace Olin Young R-MI
- James Albertus Tawney R-MN
- Winfield Scott Hammond D-MN
- Charles Russell Davis R-MN
- Frederick Clement Stevens R-MN
- Charles August Lindbergh R-MN
- James Tilghman Lloyd D-MO
- William Waller Rucker D-MO
- Joshua Willis Alexander D-MO
- Charles Ferris Booher D-MO
- Dorsey William Shackleford D-MO
- Richard Bartholdt R-MO
- Harry Marcy Coudrey R-MO
- Madison Roswell Smith D-MO
- James Robert Lamar D-MO
- Benjamin Grubb Humphreys D-MS
- Adam Monroe Byrd D-MS
- Frank Alexander Mclain D-MS
- John Humphrey Small D-NC
- Edward William Pou D-NC
- William Walton Kitchin D-NC
- Richard Nathaniel Hackett D-NC
- Edwin Yates Webb D-NC
- William Thomas Crawford D-NC
- Asle Jorgenson Gronna R-ND
- Thomas Frank Marshall R-ND
- Gilbert Monell Hitchcock D-NE
- Benjamin Franklin Howell R-NJ
- Ira Wells Wood R-NJ
- Charles Newell Fowler R-NJ
- Richard Wayne Parker R-NJ
- Le Gage Pratt D-NJ
- Eugene Walter Leake D-NJ
- James Alphonsus Hamill D-NJ
- George Arthur Bartlett D-NV
- William Willets Cocks R-NY
- George Henry Lindsay D-NY
- Charles Tappan Dunwell R-NY
- Otto Godfrey Foelker R-NY
- Charles Blakeslee Law R-NY
- William Musgrave Calder R-NY
- Daniel Joseph Riordan D-NY
- Henry Mayer Goldfogle D-NY
- William Sulzer D-NY
- Francis Burton Harrison D-NY
- George Winthrop Fairchild R-NY
- Cyrus Durey R-NY
- James Schoolcraft Sherman R-NY
- Charles Luman Knapp R-NY
- James Breck Perkins R-NY
- Peter Augustus Porter O-NY
- William Henry Ryan D-NY
- Edward Butterfield Vreeland R-NY
- Nicholas Longworth R-OH
- Herman Philip Goebel R-OH
- Isaac R. Sherwood D-OH
- Henry Towne Bannon R-OH
- Albert Douglas R-OH
- Beman Gates Dawes R-OH
- Capell Lane Weems R-OH
- William Albert Ashbrook D-OH
- James Kennedy R-OH
- Theodore Elijah Burton R-OH
- Elmer Lincoln Fulton D-OK
- James Sanford Davenport D-OK
- Charles David Carter D-OK
- Henry Harrison Bingham R-PA
- Reuben Osborne Moon R-PA
- George Deardorff Mccreary R-PA
- Thomas Stalker Butler R-PA
- Henry Burd Cassel R-PA
- Thomas David Nicholls D-PA
- John Thomas Lenahan D-PA
- Charles Napoleon Brumm R-PA
- John Hoover Rothermel D-PA
- William Bauchop Wilson D-PA
- John Geiser Mchenry D-PA
- Benjamin Kurtz Focht R-PA
- Marlin Edgar Olmsted R-PA
- John Merriman Reynolds R-PA
- Charles Frederick Barclay R-PA
- Ernest Francis Acheson R-PA
- Arthur Laban Bates R-PA
- Joseph Davis Brodhead D-PA
- Nelson Platt Wheeler R-PA
- William Harrison Graham R-PA
- Andrew Jackson Barchfeld R-PA
- George Swinton Legaré D-SC
- Wyatt Aiken D-SC
- Eben Wever Martin R-SD
- William Henry Parker R-SD
- Nathan Wesley Hale R-TN
- Finis James Garrett D-TN
- George Washington Gordon D-TN
- Alexander White Gregg D-TX
- James Luther Slayden D-TX
- William Robert Smith D-TX
- William Atkinson Jones D-VA
- Harry Lee Maynard D-VA
- Edward Watts Saunders D-VA
- Carter Glass D-VA
- Charles Creighton Carlin D-VA
- Campbell Bascom Slemp R-VA
- Campbell Slemp R-VA
- Henry De La Warr Flood D-VA
- David Johnson Foster R-VT
- Henry Allen Cooper R-WI
- John Mandt Nelson R-WI
- James William Murphy D-WI
- William Joseph Cary R-WI
- William Henry Stafford R-WI
- Charles Herman Weisse D-WI
- John Jacob Esch R-WI
- James Henry Davidson R-WI
- Elmer Addison Morse R-WI
- John James Jenkins R-WI
- William Pallister Hubbard R-WV
- George Cookman Sturgiss R-WV
- Joseph Holt Gaines R-WV
- James Anthony Hughes R-WV
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To suspend the rules and pass S. J. RES. 51…: House Vote, May 11, 1908,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/60-H-147/to-suspend-the-rules-and-pass-s-j-res (accessed 2026-10-17).