House roll call 31 · 4th Congress · May 23, 1796
To recede from disagreement to the Senate amendment to H.R. 166, which amendment retains the rank of major general.
On May 23, 1796, the House voted 37–45 (HR 166). Result: failed. By party: Others 37–45.
During the 4th Congress (1795–1796), George Washington was president.
- Yes
- 37
- No
- 45
- Did not vote
- 33
- Date
- May 23, 1796
By party
- Others37 yes · 45 no · 33 didn’t vote
How each representative voted: Yes
- Chauncey Goodrich O-CT
- Joshua Coit O-CT
- Nathaniel Smith O-CT
- Roger Griswold O-CT
- Uriah Tracy O-CT
- John Milledge O-GA
- Samuel Lyman O-MA
- Dwight Foster O-MA
- John Reed O-MA
- Fisher Ames O-MA
- Theophilus Bradbury O-MA
- Peleg Wadsworth O-MA
- George Thacher O-MA
- William Hindman O-MD
- William Vans Murray O-MD
- Abiel Foster O-NH
- Jeremiah Smith O-NH
- Nicholas Gilman O-NH
- Isaac Smith O-NJ
- Mark Thomson O-NJ
- Thomas Henderson O-NJ
- Ezekiel Gilbert O-NY
- John Evert Van Alen O-NY
- Henry Glen O-NY
- William Cooper O-NY
- John Swanwick O-PA
- Frederick Augustus Conrad Muhlenberg O-PA
- Richard Thomas O-PA
- Samuel Sitgreaves O-PA
- John Wilkes Kittera O-PA
- Andrew Gregg O-PA
- William Findley O-PA
- Benjamin Bourne O-RI
- Francis Malbone O-RI
- William Loughton Smith O-SC
- Robert Goodloe Harper O-SC
- Robert Rutherford O-VA
How each representative voted: No
- Zephaniah Swift O-CT
- Abraham Baldwin O-GA
- Christopher Greenup O-KY
- William Lyman O-MA
- George Dent O-MD
- Richard Sprigg Jr. O-MD
- Jeremiah Crabb O-MD
- Thomas Sprigg O-MD
- Samuel Smith O-MD
- James Holland O-NC
- Matthew Locke O-NC
- Jesse Franklin O-NC
- Absalom Tatom O-NC
- Nathaniel Macon O-NC
- James Gillespie O-NC
- William Barry Grove O-NC
- Dempsey Burges O-NC
- Thomas Blount O-NC
- Nathan Bryan O-NC
- Aaron Kitchell O-NJ
- Jonathan Nicoll Havens O-NY
- Philip Van Cortlandt O-NY
- John Hathorn O-NY
- Theodorus Bailey O-NY
- John Williams O-NY
- Samuel Maclay O-PA
- David Bard O-PA
- Albert Gallatin O-PA
- Wade Hampton O-SC
- Lemuel Benton O-SC
- Richard Winn O-SC
- Samuel Earle O-SC
- George Jackson O-VA
- Francis Preston O-VA
- Isaac Coles O-VA
- Abraham Bedford Venable O-VA
- Thomas Claiborne O-VA
- William Branch Giles O-VA
- Carter Bassett Harrison O-VA
- Samuel Jordan Cabell O-VA
- Anthony New O-VA
- Richard Brent O-VA
- John Nicholas O-VA
- John Heath O-VA
- Israel Smith O-VT
Did not vote
- James Davenport O-CT
- James Hillhouse O-CT
- Samuel Whittlesey Dana O-CT
- John Patten O-DE
- Alexander Dalrymple Orr O-KY
- Theodore Sedgwick O-MA
- Thomson Joseph Skinner O-MA
- Nathaniel Freeman Jr. O-MA
- George Leonard O-MA
- Joseph Bradley Varnum O-MA
- Benjamin Goodhue O-MA
- Samuel Sewall O-MA
- Henry Dearborn O-MA
- Gabriel Duvall O-MD
- William Craik O-MD
- Gabriel Christie O-MD
- William Francis Strudwick O-NC
- John Samuel Sherburne O-NH
- Jonathan Dayton O-NJ
- Edward Livingston O-NY
- John Richards O-PA
- Daniel Hiester O-PA
- George Ege O-PA
- Thomas Hartley O-PA
- Elisha Reynolds Potter O-RI
- Andrew Jackson O-TN
- Andrew Moore O-VA
- George Hancock O-VA
- Josiah Parker O-VA
- John Page O-VA
- John Clopton O-VA
- James Madison Jr. O-VA
- Daniel Buck O-VT
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To recede from disagreement to the Senate…: House Vote, May 23, 1796,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/4-H-31/to-recede-from-disagreement-to-the-senate-amendment-to (accessed 2026-10-17).