House roll call 3 · 28th Congress · Dec 4, 1843
To amend resolution adopting the rules of the previous house, by adding "except the rule generally known as the 21st rule of the house" thus striking out the 21
On Dec 4, 1843, the House voted 91–95. Result: failed. By party: Democrats 45–81, Others 46–14. 45 members voted against their own party.
During the 28th Congress (1843–1844), John Tyler was president.
- Yes
- 91
- No
- 95
- Did not vote
- 48
- Date
- Dec 4, 1843
By party
- Others46 yes · 14 no · 24 didn’t vote
- Democrats45 yes · 81 no · 24 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- Thomas Hart Seymour D-CT voted yes
- John Stewart D-CT voted yes
- George Smith Catlin D-CT voted yes
- Samuel Simons D-CT voted yes
- Robert Dale Owen D-IN voted yes
- Thomas Jefferson Henley D-IN voted yes
- Thomas Smith D-IN voted yes
- William John Brown D-IN voted yes
- Joseph Albert Wright D-IN voted yes
- John Pettit D-IN voted yes
- Andrew Kennedy D-IN voted yes
- William Parmenter D-MA voted yes
- Henry Williams D-MA voted yes
- Joshua Herrick D-ME voted yes
- Robert Pinckney Dunlap D-ME voted yes
- Hannibal Hamlin D-ME voted yes
- Robert Mcclelland D-MI voted yes
- James Bennett Hunt D-MI voted yes
- John Parker Hale D-NH voted yes
- Lucius Quintius Cincinnatus Elmer D-NJ voted yes
- George Sykes D-NJ voted yes
- Littleton Kirkpatrick D-NJ voted yes
- William Brown Maclay D-NY voted yes
- Moses Gage Leonard D-NY voted yes
- Joseph Halstead Anderson D-NY voted yes
- Richard David Davis D-NY voted yes
- James Graham Clinton D-NY voted yes
- David Lowrey Seymour D-NY voted yes
- Lemuel Stetson D-NY voted yes
- Chesselden Ellis D-NY voted yes
- Charles Swan Benton D-NY voted yes
- Orville Hungerford D-NY voted yes
- Samuel Beardsley D-NY voted yes
- Jeremiah Eaton Cary D-NY voted yes
- Orville Robinson D-NY voted yes
- Horace Wheaton D-NY voted yes
- George Oscar Rathbun D-NY voted yes
- Amasa Dana D-NY voted yes
- William Spring Hubbell D-NY voted yes
- Emery Davis Potter D-OH voted yes
- Joseph Jefferson Mcdowell D-OH voted yes
- Joseph Morris D-OH voted yes
- Ezra Dean D-OH voted yes
- John T. Smith D-PA voted yes
- Paul Dillingham Jr. D-VT voted yes
How each representative voted: Yes
- Thomas Hart Seymour D-CT
- John Stewart D-CT
- George Smith Catlin D-CT
- Samuel Simons D-CT
- George Brydges Rodney O-DE
- John J. Hardin O-IL
- Robert Dale Owen D-IN
- Thomas Jefferson Henley D-IN
- Thomas Smith D-IN
- William John Brown D-IN
- Joseph Albert Wright D-IN
- John Pettit D-IN
- Samuel Caldwell Sample O-IN
- Andrew Kennedy D-IN
- John White O-KY
- Robert Charles Winthrop O-MA
- Daniel Putnam King O-MA
- William Parmenter D-MA
- Charles Hudson O-MA
- John Quincy Adams O-MA
- Henry Williams D-MA
- Joseph Grinnell O-MA
- Joshua Herrick D-ME
- Robert Pinckney Dunlap D-ME
- Hannibal Hamlin D-ME
- Robert Mcclelland D-MI
- James Bennett Hunt D-MI
- Thomas Lanier Clingman O-NC
- John Parker Hale D-NH
- Lucius Quintius Cincinnatus Elmer D-NJ
- George Sykes D-NJ
- Littleton Kirkpatrick D-NJ
- William Wright O-NJ
- Jonas Phillips Phoenix O-NY
- William Brown Maclay D-NY
- Moses Gage Leonard D-NY
- Hamilton Fish O-NY
- Joseph Halstead Anderson D-NY
- Richard David Davis D-NY
- James Graham Clinton D-NY
- David Lowrey Seymour D-NY
- Daniel Dewey Barnard O-NY
- Charles Rogers O-NY
- Lemuel Stetson D-NY
- Chesselden Ellis D-NY
- Charles Swan Benton D-NY
- Orville Hungerford D-NY
- Samuel Beardsley D-NY
- Jeremiah Eaton Cary D-NY
- Orville Robinson D-NY
- Horace Wheaton D-NY
- George Oscar Rathbun D-NY
- Amasa Dana D-NY
- Thomas J. Patterson O-NY
- Charles Holker Carroll O-NY
- William Spring Hubbell D-NY
- Asher Tyler O-NY
- William Abbott Moseley O-NY
- Albert Smith O-NY
- Washington Hunt O-NY
- Robert Cumming Schenck O-OH
- Joseph Vance O-OH
- Emery Davis Potter D-OH
- Joseph Jefferson Mcdowell D-OH
- John Inskeep Vanmeter O-OH
- Elias Florence O-OH
- Samuel Finley Vinton O-OH
- Perley Brown Johnson O-OH
- Alexander Harper O-OH
- Joseph Morris D-OH
- Ezra Dean D-OH
- Daniel Rose Tilden O-OH
- Joshua Reed Giddings O-OH
- Edward Joy Morris O-PA
- Joseph Reed Ingersoll O-PA
- John T. Smith D-PA
- Michael Hutchinson Jenks O-PA
- Abraham Robinson Mcilvaine O-PA
- Jeremiah Brown O-PA
- Henry Frick O-PA
- Alexander Ramsey O-PA
- James Irvin O-PA
- John Dickey O-PA
- Charles Manning Reed O-PA
- Joseph Buffington O-PA
- Henry Young Cranston O-RI
- Elisha Reynolds Potter O-RI
- Solomon Foot O-VT
- Jacob Collamer O-VT
- George Perkins Marsh O-VT
- Paul Dillingham Jr. D-VT
How each representative voted: No
- James Dellet O-AL
- James Edwin Belser D-AL
- Dixon Hall Lewis D-AL
- William Winter Payne D-AL
- George Smith Houston D-AL
- Felix Grundy Mcconnell D-AL
- Edward Cross D-AR
- Absalom Harris Chappell O-GA
- Howell Cobb D-GA
- Hugh Anderson Haralson D-GA
- John Henry Lumpkin D-GA
- William Henry Stiles D-GA
- Robert Smith D-IL
- John Alexander Mcclernand D-IL
- Orlando Bell Ficklin D-IL
- John Wentworth D-IL
- Stephen Arnold Douglas D-IL
- Joseph Pendleton Hoge D-IL
- John Wesley Davis D-IN
- Linn Boyd D-KY
- Willis Green O-KY
- Henry Grider O-KY
- George Alfred Caldwell D-KY
- James W. Stone D-KY
- William Poindexter Thomasson O-KY
- Garrett Davis O-KY
- Richard French D-KY
- John Wooleston Tibbatts D-KY
- John Slidell D-LA
- Alcée Louis La Branche D-LA
- Pierre Jean Baptiste Evariste Bossier D-LA
- Gustavus Miller Bower D-MO
- James Butler Bowlin D-MO
- James Hugh Relfe D-MO
- James Madison Hughes D-MO
- John Jameson D-MO
- Jacob Thompson D-MS
- Daniel Moreau Barringer O-NC
- David Settle Reid D-NC
- Edmund Deberry O-NC
- Romulus Mitchell Saunders D-NC
- James Iver Mckay D-NC
- John Reeves Jones Daniel D-NC
- Archibald Hunter Arrington D-NC
- Kenneth Rayner O-NC
- Edmund Burke D-NH
- John Randall Reding D-NH
- Moses Norris Jr. D-NH
- Isaac Gray Farlee D-NJ
- Selah Brewster Strong D-NY
- Henry Cruse Murphy D-NY
- Jeremiah Russell D-NY
- Zadock Pratt D-NY
- Preston King D-NY
- John B. Weller D-OH
- Henry St. John D-OH
- Heman Allen Moore D-OH
- Jacob Brinkerhoff D-OH
- William Cochran Mccauslen D-OH
- Charles Jared Ingersoll D-PA
- Jacob Senewell Yost D-PA
- John Ritter D-PA
- Richard Brodhead D-PA
- Benjamin Alden Bidlack D-PA
- James Black D-PA
- William Wilkins D-PA
- Samuel Hays D-PA
- James Augustus Black D-SC
- Richard Franklin Simpson D-SC
- Joseph Addison Woodward D-SC
- John Campbell D-SC
- Isaac Edward Holmes D-SC
- Robert Barnwell Rhett D-SC
- Andrew Johnson D-TN
- William Tandy Senter O-TN
- Julius W. Blackwell D-TN
- Alvan Cullom D-TN
- George Washington Jones D-TN
- Aaron Venable Brown D-TN
- Joseph Hopkins Peyton O-TN
- Cave Johnson D-TN
- Milton Brown O-TN
- Archibald Atkinson D-VA
- George Coke Dromgoole D-VA
- Walter Coles D-VA
- Edmund Wilcox Hubard D-VA
- Thomas Walker Gilmer D-VA
- Henry Alexander Wise D-VA
- Willoughby Newton O-VA
- Samuel Chilton O-VA
- William Lucas D-VA
- William Taylor D-VA
- Augustus Alexandria Chapman D-VA
- George Washington Hopkins D-VA
- Lewis Steenrod D-VA
Did not vote
- William Lowndes Yancey D-AL
- Reuben Chapman D-AL
- Alexander Hamilton Stephens O-GA
- Duncan Lamont Clinch O-GA
- Edward Junius Black D-GA
- Caleb Blood Smith O-IN
- John Bennett Dawson D-LA
- Isaac Edward Morse D-LA
- Amos Abbott O-MA
- Osmyn Baker O-MA
- Julius Rockwell O-MA
- Barker Burnell O-MA
- John M. S. Causin O-MD
- Francis Brengle O-MD
- John Wethered O-MD
- John Pendleton Kennedy O-MD
- Jacob Alexander Preston O-MD
- Thomas Ara Spence O-MD
- Luther Severance O-ME
- Freeman Harlow Morse O-ME
- Benjamin White D-ME
- Shepard Cary D-ME
- Lucius Lyon D-MI
- Robert Whyte Roberts D-MS
- Tilghman Mayfield Tucker D-MS
- William Henry Hammett D-MS
- Levi D. Carpenter D-NY
- Smith Meade Purdy D-NY
- Byram Green D-NY
- Alexander Duncan D-OH
- Alfred Parish Stone D-OH
- James Mathews D-OH
- Edward Stowe Hamlin O-OH
- Henry Roelif Brinkerhoff D-OH
- Almon Heath Read D-PA
- George Fuller D-PA
- James Pollock O-PA
- Henry Nes O-PA
- Andrew Stewart O-PA
- Henry Donnel Foster D-PA
- Cornelius Darragh O-PA
- Armistead Burt D-SC
- David W. Dickinson O-TN
- John Baptista Ashe O-TN
- William Leftwich Goggin O-VA
- John Winston Jones D-VA
- Thomas Henry Bayly D-VA
- George William Summers O-VA
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To amend resolution adopting the rules of…: House Vote, Dec 4, 1843,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/28-H-3/to-amend-resolution-adopting-the-rules-of-the-previous (accessed 2026-10-17).