House roll call 84 · 26th Congress · Jan 21, 1840
To sustain the decision of the chair that an amendment can not be introduced which is in substance the same as one that has been tabled.
On Jan 21, 1840, the House voted 121–64. Result: passed. By party: Others 95–0, Democrats 26–64. 26 members voted against their own party.
During the 26th Congress (1839–1840), Martin Van Buren was president.
- Yes
- 121
- No
- 64
- Did not vote
- 70
- Date
- Jan 21, 1840
By party
- Democrats26 yes · 64 no · 37 didn’t vote
- Others95 yes · 0 no · 33 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- Dixon Hall Lewis D-AL voted yes
- Zadok Casey D-IL voted yes
- John Carr D-IN voted yes
- Tilghman Ashurst Howard D-IN voted yes
- William Orlando Butler D-KY voted yes
- Joshua Adams Lowell D-ME voted yes
- Thomas Davee D-ME voted yes
- Albert Gallatin Brown D-MS voted yes
- Charles Biddle Shepard D-NC voted yes
- Charles Fisher D-NC voted yes
- Thomas Birdsall Jackson D-NY voted yes
- Augustus Cincinnatus Hand D-NY voted yes
- Edward Rogers D-NY voted yes
- William Doan D-OH voted yes
- Enos Hook D-PA voted yes
- William Beatty D-PA voted yes
- Isaac Edward Holmes D-SC voted yes
- Sampson Hale Butler D-SC voted yes
- Francis Wilkinson Pickens D-SC voted yes
- Thomas De Lage Sumter D-SC voted yes
- John King Griffin D-SC voted yes
- Harvey Magee Watterson D-TN voted yes
- Robert Craig D-VA voted yes
- Joseph Johnson D-VA voted yes
- John Smith D-VT voted yes
- Isaac Fletcher D-VT voted yes
How each representative voted: Yes
- George Whitfield Crabb O-AL
- Dixon Hall Lewis D-AL
- James Dellet O-AL
- Joseph Trumbull O-CT
- William Lucius Storrs O-CT
- Thomas Wheeler Williams O-CT
- Thomas Burr Osborne O-CT
- Truman Smith O-CT
- John Hall Brockway O-CT
- Edward Junius Black O-GA
- Eugenius Aristides Nisbet O-GA
- Julius Caesar Alford O-GA
- Mark Anthony Cooper O-GA
- Richard Wylly Habersham O-GA
- William Crosby Dawson O-GA
- Zadok Casey D-IL
- John Todd Stuart O-IL
- George H. Proffit O-IN
- John Carr D-IN
- James Rariden O-IN
- Tilghman Ashurst Howard D-IN
- Philip Triplett O-KY
- Joseph Rogers Underwood O-KY
- Sherrod Williams O-KY
- Simeon H. Anderson O-KY
- Willis Green O-KY
- John Pope O-KY
- William Jordan Graves O-KY
- John White O-KY
- Landaff Watson Andrews O-KY
- Garrett Davis O-KY
- William Orlando Butler D-KY
- Edward Douglass White O-LA
- Thomas Withers Chinn O-LA
- Rice Garland O-LA
- Abbott Lawrence O-MA
- Leverett Saltonstall O-MA
- Osmyn Baker O-MA
- George Nixon Briggs O-MA
- William Barron Calhoun O-MA
- William Soden Hastings O-MA
- John Reed O-MA
- John Quincy Adams O-MA
- John Dennis O-MD
- William Cost Johnson O-MD
- Benjamin Randall O-ME
- George Evans O-ME
- Joshua Adams Lowell D-ME
- Thomas Davee D-ME
- Albert Gallatin Brown D-MS
- Kenneth Rayner O-NC
- Edward Stanly O-NC
- Charles Biddle Shepard D-NC
- Edmund Deberry O-NC
- Charles Fisher D-NC
- James Graham O-NC
- Joseph Fitz Randolph O-NJ
- Thomas Birdsall Jackson D-NY
- James Monroe O-NY
- Josiah Ogden Hoffman O-NY
- Moses Hicks Grinnell O-NY
- Charles Johnston O-NY
- Rufus Palen O-NY
- Hiram Paine Hunt O-NY
- Daniel Dewey Barnard O-NY
- Anson Brown O-NY
- David Abel Russell O-NY
- Augustus Cincinnatus Hand D-NY
- Peter Joseph Wagner O-NY
- Edward Rogers D-NY
- Christopher Morgan O-NY
- Francis Granger O-NY
- Thomas Kempshall O-NY
- Seth Merrill Gates O-NY
- Richard Pratt Marvin O-NY
- Charles F. Mitchell O-NY
- Patrick Gaines Goode O-OH
- Thomas Corwin O-OH
- William Doan D-OH
- William Key Bond O-OH
- Samson Mason O-OH
- Joshua Reed Giddings O-OH
- John Sergeant O-PA
- Charles Naylor O-PA
- Edward Davies O-PA
- Francis James O-PA
- John Edwards O-PA
- William Simonton O-PA
- James Cooper O-PA
- Charles Ogle O-PA
- Enos Hook D-PA
- Richard Biddle O-PA
- William Beatty D-PA
- Thomas Henry O-PA
- Joseph Leonard Tillinghast O-RI
- Robert Bennie Cranston O-RI
- Isaac Edward Holmes D-SC
- Sampson Hale Butler D-SC
- Francis Wilkinson Pickens D-SC
- Waddy Thompson Jr. O-SC
- Thomas De Lage Sumter D-SC
- John King Griffin D-SC
- William Blount Carter O-TN
- William Bowen Campbell O-TN
- John Bell O-TN
- Meredith Poindexter Gentry O-TN
- Harvey Magee Watterson D-TN
- John Wesley Crockett O-TN
- Christopher Harris Williams O-TN
- John Hill O-VA
- William Leftwich Goggin O-VA
- John Taliaferro O-VA
- John Minor Botts O-VA
- James Garland O-VA
- Robert Craig D-VA
- Joseph Johnson D-VA
- Hiland Hall O-VT
- William Slade O-VT
- Horace Everett O-VT
- John Smith D-VT
- Isaac Fletcher D-VT
How each representative voted: No
- Reuben Chapman D-AL
- John Reynolds D-IL
- Thomas Smith D-IN
- Linn Boyd D-KY
- William Parmenter D-MA
- Henry Williams D-MA
- Philip Francis Thomas D-MD
- John Tolley Hood Worthington D-MD
- James Carroll D-MD
- Jr. Hillen Solomon D-MD
- Francis Thomas D-MD
- Nathan Clifford D-ME
- Albert Smith D-ME
- Virgil Delphini Parris D-ME
- Hugh Johnston Anderson D-ME
- John Jameson D-MO
- James Iver Mckay D-NC
- Micajah Thomas Hawkins D-NC
- William Montgomery D-NC
- John Hill D-NC
- Henry William Connor D-NC
- Charles Gordon Atherton D-NH
- Edmund Burke D-NH
- Ira Allen Eastman D-NH
- Jared Warner Williams D-NH
- Tristram Shaw D-NH
- James De La Montanya D-NY
- Nathaniel Jones D-NY
- Aaron Vanderpoel D-NY
- John Fine D-NY
- Andrew Wheeler Doig D-NY
- John Gelston Floyd D-NY
- Amasa Dana D-NY
- Stephen Banks Leonard D-NY
- Nehemiah Hezekiah Earll D-NY
- Theron Rudd Strong D-NY
- Meredith Mallory D-NY
- Alexander Duncan D-OH
- John B. Weller D-OH
- William Medill D-OH
- Isaac Parrish D-OH
- Daniel Parkhurst Leadbetter D-OH
- George Sweeny D-OH
- John Hastings D-OH
- Lemuel Paynter D-PA
- John Davis D-PA
- David Douglas Wagener D-PA
- Peter Newhard D-PA
- George May Keim D-PA
- James Gerry D-PA
- William Sterrett Ramsey D-PA
- George Mcculloch D-PA
- Albert Gallatin Marchand D-PA
- Abraham Mcclellan D-TN
- Julius W. Blackwell D-TN
- Hopkins Lacy Turney D-TN
- Aaron Venable Brown D-TN
- Cave Johnson D-TN
- John Winston Jones D-VA
- George Coke Dromgoole D-VA
- Linn Banks D-VA
- William Lucas D-VA
- Green Berry Samuels D-VA
- Lewis Steenrod D-VA
Did not vote
- David Hubbard D-AL
- Edward Cross D-AR
- William Whiting Boardman O-CT
- Thomas Robinson Jr. D-DE
- Hines Holt O-GA
- Lott Warren O-GA
- Thomas Butler King O-GA
- Walter Terry Colquitt O-GA
- John Wesley Davis D-IN
- William Watson Wick D-IN
- Henry Smith Lane O-IN
- John Burton Thompson O-KY
- Richard Hawes O-KY
- John Moore O-LA
- Robert Charles Winthrop O-MA
- Caleb Cushing O-MA
- Levi Lincoln O-MA
- Daniel Jenifer O-MD
- Isaac Edwin Crary D-MI
- John Miller D-MO
- Jacob Thompson D-MS
- Jesse Atherton Bynum D-NC
- Lewis Williams O-NC
- Daniel Bailey Ryall D-NJ
- Joseph Kille D-NJ
- Peter Dumont Vroom D-NJ
- Philemon Dickerson D-NJ
- William Raworth Cooper D-NJ
- Edward Curtis O-NY
- Gouverneur Kemble D-NY
- John Ely D-NY
- Nicholas Bartlett Doe O-NY
- David P. Brewster D-NY
- Thomas Cotton Chittenden O-NY
- John Holmes Prentiss D-NY
- Judson Allen D-NY
- John Chamberlain Clark O-NY
- Luther Christopher Peck O-NY
- Millard Fillmore O-NY
- Jeremiah Morrow O-OH
- Calvary Morris O-OH
- Joseph Ridgway O-OH
- Jonathan Taylor D-OH
- John William Allen O-OH
- David Austin Starkweather D-OH
- Henry Swearingen D-OH
- George Washington Toland O-PA
- Joseph Fornance D-PA
- Charles Mcclure D-PA
- William Wilson Potter D-PA
- David Petrikin D-PA
- Robert Hanna Hammond D-PA
- Samuel Wells Morris D-PA
- Isaac Leet D-PA
- Henry Marie Brackenridge O-PA
- John Galbraith D-PA
- Robert Barnwell Rhett D-SC
- John Campbell D-SC
- James Rogers D-SC
- Joseph Lanier Williams O-TN
- Francis Mallory O-VA
- Joel Holleman D-VA
- Francis Everod Rives D-VA
- Walter Coles D-VA
- Henry Alexander Wise O-VA
- Robert Mercer Taliaferro Hunter O-VA
- Charles Fenton Mercer O-VA
- William Mason Mccarty O-VA
- George Washington Hopkins O-VA
- Andrew Beirne D-VA
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To sustain the decision of the chair that an…: House Vote, Jan 21…,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/26-H-84/to-sustain-the-decision-of-the-chair-that-an (accessed 2026-10-17).