House roll call 164 · 25th Congress · May 2, 1838
To recommit the report of the select committee on the death of hon. J. Cilley, with the petitions and memorials presented to the house upon the subject of dueli
On May 2, 1838, the House voted 89–86. Result: passed. By party: Others 12–77, Democrats 77–8, Independents 0–1. 8 members voted against their own party.
During the 25th Congress (1837–1838), Martin Van Buren was president.
- Yes
- 89
- No
- 86
- Did not vote
- 82
- Date
- May 2, 1838
By party
- Democrats77 yes · 8 no · 49 didn’t vote
- Others12 yes · 77 no · 33 didn’t vote
- Independents0 yes · 1 no
Who broke with their party
- Benjamin Chew Howard D-MD voted no
- Albert Galliton Harrison D-MO voted no
- Gouverneur Kemble D-NY voted no
- John Peter Richardson D-SC voted no
- James Wood Bouldin D-VA voted no
- Walter Coles D-VA voted no
- James Murray Mason D-VA voted no
- Isaac Samuels Pennybacker D-VA voted no
How each representative voted: Yes
- Reuben Chapman D-AL
- Joshua Lanier Martin D-AL
- Archibald Yell D-AR
- Isaac Toucey D-CT
- Samuel Ingham D-CT
- Elisha Haley D-CT
- Lancelot Phelps D-CT
- Orrin Holt D-CT
- Charles Eaton Haynes D-GA
- Zadok Casey D-IL
- Ratliff Boon D-IN
- Richard Fletcher D-MA
- William Parmenter D-MA
- Levi Lincoln O-MA
- John Tolley Hood Worthington D-MD
- Francis Thomas D-MD
- John Fairfield D-ME
- Hugh Johnston Anderson D-ME
- Joseph Cobham Noyes O-ME
- Thomas Davee D-ME
- Isaac Edwin Crary D-MI
- James Iver Mckay D-NC
- William Montgomery D-NC
- Henry William Connor D-NC
- Charles Gordon Atherton D-NH
- James Farrington D-NH
- Jared Warner Williams D-NH
- Joseph Weeks D-NH
- Samuel Cushman D-NH
- Abraham Vanderveer D-NY
- Churchill Caldom Cambreleng D-NY
- Ely Moore D-NY
- Obadiah Titus D-NY
- Nathaniel Jones D-NY
- John Curtis Brodhead D-NY
- Robert Mcclellan D-NY
- Zadock Pratt D-NY
- Albert Gallup D-NY
- John Isaac De Graff D-NY
- John Palmer D-NY
- James Bradley Spencer D-NY
- John Edwards D-NY
- Abraham Phineas Grant D-NY
- Henry Allen Foster D-NY
- Isaac Hopkins Bronson D-NY
- John Holmes Prentiss D-NY
- Amasa Junius Parker D-NY
- John Chamberlain Clark D-NY
- Andrew DeWitt Bruyn D-NY
- Hiram Gray D-NY
- Bennet Bicknell D-NY
- William Taylor D-NY
- William Henry Noble D-NY
- Samuel Birdsall D-NY
- Mark Hopkins Sibley O-NY
- John Tuttle Andrews D-NY
- William Patterson O-NY
- Millard Fillmore O-NY
- Alexander Duncan D-OH
- Patrick Gaines Goode O-OH
- Thomas Lyon Hamer D-OH
- Daniel Parkhurst Leadbetter D-OH
- William H. Hunter D-OH
- Andrew Williams Loomis O-OH
- Lemuel Paynter D-PA
- David Potts Jr. O-PA
- Edward Davies O-PA
- Jacob Fry Jr. D-PA
- Mathias Morris O-PA
- David Douglas Wagener D-PA
- Edward Burd Hubley D-PA
- George May Keim D-PA
- Luther Reily D-PA
- Henry Logan D-PA
- Charles Mcclure D-PA
- David Petrikin D-PA
- Robert Hanna Hammond D-PA
- Charles Ogle O-PA
- John Klingensmith Jr. D-PA
- William Beatty D-PA
- Thomas Henry O-PA
- Abraham Mcclellan D-TN
- Hopkins Lacy Turney D-TN
- Robert Craig D-VA
- George Washington Hopkins D-VA
- Andrew Beirne D-VA
- Joseph Johnson D-VA
- William Stephen Morgan D-VA
- Isaac Fletcher D-VT
How each representative voted: No
- Joab Lawler O-AL
- Francis Strother Lyon O-AL
- John Jones Milligan O-DE
- William Crosby Dawson O-GA
- William Graham O-IN
- George Hedford Dunn O-IN
- James Rariden O-IN
- William Herod O-IN
- Albert Smith White O-IN
- Edward Rumsey O-KY
- Joseph Rogers Underwood O-KY
- Sherrod Williams O-KY
- James Harlan O-KY
- John Pope I-KY
- John White O-KY
- Richard Hawes O-KY
- John Chambers O-KY
- William Wright Southgate O-KY
- Caleb Cushing O-MA
- George Nixon Briggs O-MA
- John Reed O-MA
- John Quincy Adams O-MA
- John Dennis O-MD
- Benjamin Chew Howard D-MD
- William Cost Johnson O-MD
- Albert Galliton Harrison D-MO
- Samuel Tredwell Sawyer O-NC
- Edward Stanly O-NC
- Charles Biddle Shepard O-NC
- Edmund Deberry O-NC
- Augustine Henry Shepperd O-NC
- Abraham Rencher O-NC
- James Graham O-NC
- Lewis Williams O-NC
- Charles Creighton Stratton O-NJ
- John Bancker Aycrigg O-NJ
- Joseph Fitz Randolph O-NJ
- Thomas Jones Yorke O-NJ
- Edward Curtis O-NY
- Josiah Ogden Hoffman O-NY
- Gouverneur Kemble D-NY
- David Abel Russell O-NY
- Timothy Childs O-NY
- Luther Christopher Peck O-NY
- Richard Pratt Marvin O-NY
- Charles F. Mitchell O-NY
- Thomas Corwin O-OH
- Calvary Morris O-OH
- William Key Bond O-OH
- Joseph Ridgway O-OH
- James Alexander Jr. O-OH
- Alexander Harper O-OH
- John William Allen O-OH
- Elisha Whittlesey O-OH
- Charles Dustin Coffin O-OH
- Charles Naylor O-PA
- Thomas McKean Thompson Mckennan O-PA
- Richard Biddle O-PA
- Joseph Leonard Tillinghast O-RI
- Robert Bennie Cranston O-RI
- John Campbell O-SC
- Francis Wilkinson Pickens O-SC
- John Peter Richardson D-SC
- John King Griffin O-SC
- William Blount Carter O-TN
- Joseph Lanier Williams O-TN
- William Bowen Campbell O-TN
- John Bell O-TN
- Abram Poindexter Maury O-TN
- Ebenezer J. Shields O-TN
- Richard Cheatham O-TN
- John Wesley Crockett O-TN
- Christopher Harris Williams O-TN
- Francis Mallory O-VA
- James Wood Bouldin D-VA
- Walter Coles D-VA
- Robert Mercer Taliaferro Hunter O-VA
- John Taliaferro O-VA
- John Robertson O-VA
- Charles Fenton Mercer O-VA
- James Murray Mason D-VA
- Isaac Samuels Pennybacker D-VA
- Hiland Hall O-VT
- William Slade O-VT
- Horace Everett O-VT
- Heman (of Milton) Allen O-VT
Did not vote
- George Whitfield Crabb O-AL
- Dixon Hall Lewis D-AL
- Thomas Tucker Whittlesey D-CT
- George Washington Bonaparte Towns D-GA
- George Welshman Owens D-GA
- Hopkins Holsey D-GA
- Jabez Young Jackson D-GA
- Jesse Franklin Cleveland D-GA
- Seaton Grantland D-GA
- Thomas Glascock D-GA
- Adam Wilson Snyder D-IL
- William L. May D-IL
- John Ewing O-IN
- John L. Murray D-KY
- John Calhoon O-KY
- William Jordan Graves O-KY
- Richard Hickman Menefee O-KY
- Henry Johnson O-LA
- Eleazar Wheelock Ripley D-LA
- Rice Garland O-LA
- Leverett Saltonstall O-MA
- Stephen Clarendon Phillips O-MA
- George Grennell Jr. O-MA
- William Barron Calhoun O-MA
- William Soden Hastings O-MA
- Nathaniel Briggs Borden D-MA
- James Alfred Pearce O-MD
- Isaac Mckim D-MD
- John Pendleton Kennedy O-MD
- Daniel Jenifer O-MD
- Francis Ormand Jonathan Smith D-ME
- Edward Robinson O-ME
- Jonathan Cilley D-ME
- George Evans O-ME
- Timothy Jarvis Carter D-ME
- Virgil Delphini Parris D-ME
- John Miller D-MO
- John Francis Hamtramck Claiborne D-MS
- Samuel Jameson Gholson D-MS
- Seargent Smith Prentiss O-MS
- Thomas Jefferson Word O-MS
- Jesse Atherton Bynum D-NC
- Micajah Thomas Hawkins D-NC
- John Patterson Bryan Maxwell O-NJ
- William Halstead O-NJ
- Thomas Birdsall Jackson D-NY
- Henry Vail D-NY
- Arphaxed Loomis D-NY
- Cyrus Beers D-NY
- Harvey Putnam O-NY
- Taylor Webster D-OH
- John Chaney D-OH
- Samson Mason O-OH
- Joshua Reed Giddings O-OH
- Matthias Shepler D-OH
- Daniel Kilgore D-OH
- Henry Swearingen D-OH
- George Washington Toland O-PA
- John Sergeant O-PA
- Francis Jacob Harper D-PA
- Edward Darlington O-PA
- Henry Augustus Philip Muhlenberg D-PA
- Daniel Sheffer D-PA
- William Wilson Potter D-PA
- Samuel Wells Morris D-PA
- Andrew Buchanan D-PA
- Arnold Plumer D-PA
- Hugh Swinton Legaré D-SC
- Robert Barnwell Rhett O-SC
- Franklin Harper Elmore O-SC
- Waddy Thompson Jr. O-SC
- William Kennedy Clowney O-SC
- William Stone O-TN
- James Knox Polk D-TN
- Francis Everod Rives D-VA
- John Winston Jones D-VA
- George Coke Dromgoole D-VA
- Archibald Stuart D-VA
- Henry Alexander Wise O-VA
- James Garland D-VA
- John Mercer Patton D-VA
- Linn Banks D-VA
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To recommit the report of the select…: House Vote, May 2, 1838,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/25-H-164/to-recommit-the-report-of-the-select-committee-on (accessed 2026-10-17).